• About

doubtfulsea

~ adventure fantasy

Monthly Archives: January 2020

Three Times Three (4)

31 Friday Jan 2020

Posted by Ollamh in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

As ever, dear readers, welcome.

In this posting, we come to the end of what we’ve been calling our slow-motion review of Star Wars:  The Rise of Skywalker.

image1poster.jpg

If you’ve been following along, you will know that we began with Stars Wars:  The Phantom Menace,

image2six.jpg

and have worked our way through all the films in the first trilogy

image3tril.jpg

and then the second.

image4tril.jpg

In this approach, our main idea was to try to trace what the original creator, George Lucas, intended to do in what, in time, became a duology of trilogies

image5numberseven.jpg

image6aeight.jpg

but has now, with the release of IX, has become a trilogy of trilogies.  In a brief summary from the conclusion of our last posting, we would say that, by the end of VI:

“But that new hope, promised in the first episode of the trilogy, has come true, it seems.  The Emperor is gone, Anakin has been saved, and, with the general celebrations throughout the galaxy, the suggestion is, at least, that the Empire is gone, as well. “

We then asked the question:  “What more is there to do?”

Over time, George Lucas produced several answers.  One was a complete negative:  VI is the end.  Then there was the implication that there might be more films, but not with the characters we knew from the second trilogy.  And then there has been, through interviews over a number of years, the idea that, in a third trilogy, we would see a kind of back-story to the back-story, in which we would learn that the “midi-chlorines” of the first movie—that something in the bloodstream which seems to be involved with the Force and which the boy, Anakin, is so full of, as Qui-Gon reports to Yoda—are actually the agents for something else, a group of entities called the “Whills”.  The little bits about this scheme have, in our experience, received reactions from critics which have ranged from vague interest to sweaty condemnation and, when Lucas sold his company to the Walt Disney Corporation in 2012, the Whills simply sank from sight.

This brings us back to our question:  “What more is there to do?”

That Lucas himself once considered that six was the magic number would suggest that his answer might be, “Nothing.”  And yet, more recently, he has lamented the fact he didn’t get the chance to make that third set.  Someone else did, however, and this could lead to real difficulties with the approach.  As we hope that we have shown in our last two postings, Lucas had gradually developed several main ideas over the first six films:

  1. that there were two elements to a power which somehow stood behind the Galaxy, the Force and the Dark Side, and that, at least at the beginning of The Phantom Menace, this power was out of balance
  2. in the physical world, these powers were represented by the Jedi and the Sith
  3. at some point, the Dark Side had won, the Jedi were nearly exterminated, and the Galaxy was being ruled by a Sith
  4. the chief agent of that ruler, Darth Vader (originally Anakin Skywalker), was a Jedi who had been seduced to join the Sith
  5. unbeknownst to Vader, his children, fraternal twins, had survived their traumatic birth and had grown up on different worlds, both unaware of the other
  6. in time, however, they would join together and, with other characters, bring down the Sith and save their father from what we might imagine was a kind of eternal damnation (although this last is never directly stated)

From what little we know about what might have happened if Lucas had been in charge, the next step was something to do with the midi-chlorines and the Whills.  As Lucas produced six adventure features in which the Force always appeared, but only as part of the background, we don’t believe that the final trilogy would have been a series of animated lectures on the spiritual science behind the Galaxy.  Rather, we imagine that there would have been the usual adventure element, combined, as in the case of the Force, with the Whills.  At the moment, at least, we know nothing more.

Lucas was not in charge, however, of this third trilogy, so we are left to try to understand:

  1. did the creators continue the themes of the first two?
  2. or did they head in other directions and, if so, how might they be understood in relation to those first two trilogies?

This brings us to VII, The Force Awakens.

image6poster.jpg

With that title, no matter what else happens, there is clearly some link with the first two trilogies.  And a great deal happens, the central focus of which is that a young girl, called Rey,

image7rey.jpg

who looks to be a kind of scrap-metal scavenger on a desert planet called Jakku,

image8niimaoutpost.jpg

and who rescues a small droid

image9bb8.png

which turns out to be carrying secret information.

So far, this has a very familiar ring and we’re suddenly back in A New Hope 

image10luker2.jpg

There is a switch, however.  Instead of plans for the Death Star, the information is part of a map to where Luke Skywalker has taken refuge.  As we haven’t in the past postings, we don’t intend to do a plot summary here (but here’s a LINK to one, in case you need it:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Wars:_The_Force_Awakens).

We would briefly say that other characters participate, both new, like Poe Dameron and Finn,

image11poefinn.jpg

and old friends, like Chewy and Han.

image12chewyhan.png

The opposition, something called “The First Order”, is led by a mysterious figure named “Snoke”,

image13snoke.png

who has for his enforcer a Darth Vader-wannabe, Kylo Ren,

image14kr.jpg

who is actually Ben Solo, son of Leia and Han.

The main story then becomes a quest for Luke, the protagonists, with Rey in the lead, vs the antagonists, led by Kylo Ren.  In the process, Rey gradually discovers that she is strong with the Force, which will lead her, by the film’s end to meeting a hooded figure on a distant world.

image15ls.jpg

And so we see certain elements which appear to be built upon the past:  Luke and the other characters from the second trilogy, a no one (or a seeming no one, as we’ll eventually see) with the Force, the Dark Side and its followers, all about 20 years after Return of the Jedi and the destruction of the Empire.

Nothing has really been resolved in VII, although this new version of the Empire has suffered a set-back when its new Death Star—now an entire planet—has been blown up, and so VIII

image16poster.jpg

begins with another echo from past, this time from The Empire Strikes Back:  the evacuation of a rebel base.  In this case, however, there is no ground assault and the rebels appear to have escaped, but, with a tracking device involved, they are pursued and a driving element of the plot is the rebels’ dwindling fuel supply.  (Again, if you need a plot summary, here’s a LINK:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Wars:_The_Last_Jedi)

Meanwhile, Rey’s hooded figure is, indeed, Luke, but a Luke who rejects anything to do with the Jedi and refuses to train her, which presents us with another echo, but this time a mirror opposite:  Luke and Yoda.

image17landy.jpg

When he reluctantly relents, she has moments of contact with Kylo Ren, who explains to her why Luke has gone into self-exile—at least, his version of events.  In time, he captures her and brings her to Snoke, who attempts to turn her to the Dark Side, but dies instead, killed by Ren, who then declares himself Snoke’s replacement—and here we see another opposite:  Darth Vader killed the Emperor, but, instead of claiming Palpatine’s power for himself, dies, becoming Anakin Skywalker once more.

By the film’s end, the rebels have escaped once more, Kylo Ren distracted in a duel with what is rather like the astral projection of Luke (who dies peacefully at its end), and the scene is set for a final confrontation of Ren vs Rey (who believes that Ren can be redeemed—and, once more there is an echo, this time of Luke and Vader).

So far, then, what we’ve seen in this third trilogy has continued the story into the next generation with Kylo/Ben and Rey and the Force and with a number of echoes and mirror moments from the previous trilogy.  The first trilogy ended with disaster for the protagonists, the Emperor having won and the Jedi nearly destroyed.  The conclusion of the second trilogy showed us the opposite:  the Emperor gone and the Jedi—at least one Jedi—restored.  How will this third trilogy—the ultimate part of the story—conclude?

image18poster.jpg

With all of the previous films, we’ve had the advantage of owning dvds and therefore seeing them all a number of times.  We’ve only seen The Rise of Skywalker once, several weeks ago, in a movie theatre, so we’re going mostly on a first impression and a summary (LINK:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Wars:_The_Rise_of_Skywalker).

With that in mind, using VII and VIII, we would say that the writers/directors have, as Lucas did when he finished the first trilogy, set up the following problems:

  1. is Rey now to become a Jedi?
  2. if so, should we presume that she will confront Ren?
  3. and, that being so, is Rey the ultimate “chosen one”, come to bring “balance to the Force” at long last?

All of the above, if we replaced the names with those from the second trilogy, could be questions we might have asked after The Empire Strikes Back:  1. Luke; 2. Vader; 3. Luke.  As long-time watchers of the series, we could take this in at least two directions:  a. not really knowing what to do, the writers have fallen back upon the very successful second trilogy; or, b. because they are trying to give the third trilogy the kind of closure such an elaborate series requires, they draw upon the strength of the narrative of the second trilogy as a basis, but then add to it—as perhaps we shall see.

As The Force Awakens had, as a major theme, the search for Luke, so this final film has its own search, for the revived Emperor Palpatine, who lets Kylo Ren know that he’s been behind everything, from Snope to the drawing of Ren to the Dark Side.  Recognizing that Rey is the only real opposition, he orders Ren to remove her.  In the process of searching for her, he makes the same kind of contact we had seen in the second film, but this time he reveals that she is, in fact, the Emperor’s granddaughter.  There is no explanation of who her parents were and only a flash of a scene in which they were murdered, so we know no more than what Ren tells Rey at the moment.  We also know that there have been some negative critical reactions to this, but we have tried to remain neutral, under the idea that, if Rey is really the “chosen one”, then her ancestry could be an important and powerful part of the rebalance of the Force.

The confrontation between Rey and Ren takes place

image19duel.jpg

and Rey, whose experience with the Force has grown and grown since her original encounter with Ren in the first film of the trilogy, actually kills him—but then, in something we haven’t seen before (but Palpatine had once implied something about it to Anakin as a  power of the Dark Side, in fact), she brings him back.  Instead of then continuing with the search for Palpatine, however, she returns to the island where she had found Luke at the end of The Force Awakens.  There, Luke’s spirit sends her off once more on her quest and, in the last big scene of the film, she meets her grandfather, who tells her that she must kill him in order to inherit his power.  She refuses and, joined by the now-reformed Ren, is nearly drained of her life force by the increasingly-powerful Emperor.  Ren brings her back, however, in the mirror of the previous scene in which she does so for him, and finally she defeats and destroys her grandfather, only to kiss Ren as he dies from the effort to revive her (and we might wonder why she doesn’t try bringing him back again, but that might turn the serious to the silly).

We’ve given a bit more summary here than we would like, but we’re trying to make this as clear to ourselves as we can, seeking to understand just what the creators were attempting to do in this final episode.

In answer to our earlier questions:

  1. Rey has clearly become a Jedi
  2. she has not only confronted Ren, but, through her actions, actually rescued him from the Dark Side
  3. is she the ultimate “chosen one”? that, we can’t answer. It’s true that she appears to be the Last Jedi, of the second film’s title and that she has great powers and even that she’s defeated and destroyed the Emperor at last.  As Yoda would say, “Unclear!”,  but, in the final short scene of the film, we are left with what is perhaps a clue.

Rey is seen returning to Tatooine, where she reverently buries not a person (Luke and Leia have disappeared into the Force, after all), but two light sabers, Luke’s and Leia’s.  Then, when asked by an old woman who’s been watching her, for her name, she says “Rey”, but then adds “Skywalker”, thus explaining the title of the film, but also suggesting a kind of continuity:  granddaughter of the Sith, but taught by the final Jedi, Luke, and, for a little while, Leia, and now on the rise…

image20tat.png

And, with that, the film ends and we end this extended review.  We hope that you found it interesting and we’d be glad for any and all comments and questions.

In our next posting, we’re returning to JRRT—but more about that next time.  In the meantime, thanks again for reading and

MTCIDC

CD

ps

Has anyone else noticed a passing resemblance between Kylo Ren and a major figure from another epic?

image21kr.jpgimage22snape.jpg

Three Times Three (3)

29 Wednesday Jan 2020

Posted by Ollamh in J.R.R. Tolkien, Star Wars, Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Welcome, dear readers, as ever.

We had been progressing through our big review of the final Star Wars film, The Rise of Skywalker,

image1rise.jpg

when we paused to post a brief elegy for one of our heroes, Christopher Tolkien,

image2ct.jpg

who died, age 95, earlier in January.

We continue now with the third part of our review.

We began with the idea of literary trilogies, like The Lord of the Rings,

image3lotr.jpg

although, as we know, it wasn’t conceived as such, it has come to be considered so.

In such groupings, the pattern tends to be that a situation is set up in the first, is developed in the second, and is resolved in the third, in a pattern familiar throughout the western world, from wishes to fairy tales.

The first Star Wars trilogy–The Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones, Revenge of the Sith—

image4first.jpg

has brought us several situations, in fact:

  1. a galaxy in turmoil—revolt which becomes civil war

image5geonosis.jpg

  1. a turmoil secretly created by a figure who originally posed as a defender of order, Senator Palpatine, who, in reality, is the evil Sith, Dark Sidious,

image6sid.jpg

  1. and who has done this not only to achieve power, but to destroy the opposite of the Sith, the Jedi.

image7jeid.jpeg

In the process, he has turned what some of the Jedi hoped was their savior, who was to bring “balance to the Force” (the mystic power which forms the universe), Anakin Skywalker, into his monstrous apprentice, Darth Vader.

image8ana.jpg

image9vader.jpg

So, we begin the second trilogy, the original trilogy and, in some people’s opinion, the most successful.

image10second.jpg

For ourselves, as we’ve already expressed, we are very reluctant to be judgmental.  Huge amounts of creativity and just plain hard work went into the whole process, and, because it’s meant to be seen as a series of nine films, we will continue to try to understand it as just that:  a trilogy of trilogies.

So here we are, at the opening of the second trilogy, with IV, tantalizingly subtitled, A New Hope.

image11hope.jpg

The third of the first trilogy, The Revenge of the Sith,

image12revenge.jpg

ended with what seemed like the total success of the new galactic emperor, Darth Sidious.

image13sid.png

He was now sole ruler (although the Senate still seemed to exist for the moment), had almost totally destroyed the Jedi, and had turned the hope for balance into his enforcer.

image14vader.jpg

At the same time, that enforcer’s children have survived, unbeknownst to him, or the emperor, growing up to be, on the one hand, a princess, Leia,

image15leia.jpg

and, on the other, Luke, a farmhand.

image16luke.jpg

Their paths cross when Leia, a spy for the rebellion against the Empire, hides a message in a droid, R2D2,

image17r2.jpg

and, while she is captured, the droid escapes to the home planet of the farmhand, Tatooine, along with another droid, C3PO.

image18c3.jpg

Luke is intrigued by the message (cunningly broadcast by R2D2)

image19leia.jpg

and the story sets off on a rescue mission, picking up, along the way, one of the few surviving Jedi, Obi-wan Kenobi,

image20obi.jpg

as well as two smugglers, Han Solo and his friend, Chewbacca.

image21han.jpg

Obi-wan reveals that Luke is, in reality, the son of an old friend, a Jedi, who was “murdered” by his apprentice, and gives Luke his father’s light saber.  And, at that moment, we see the beginning of the prophecy suggested in the title:  if Leia, the princess and spy, and Luke, the farmhand and possible Jedi, can be brought together, they may then become the basis of a turn in the plot and the emperor and his minion, Darth Vader, may not be so secure as they believe.

The princess is rescued, of course, from the technological threat to the galaxy, the Death Star,

image22deathstar.jpg

and Luke sees Darth Vader for the first time, apparently striking down Obi-wan.

image23obi.jpg

The story does not, however, now bring Luke and Leia into direct confrontation with Darth Sidious and Darth Vader.  Instead, we see Luke, feeling the effects of the Force, become the agent of the destruction of the Death Star.

image24death.jpg

And so we see, as well, that that subtitle may be true.

In the second film of this trilogy, however, The Empire Strikes Back,

image25emp.jpg

although the Emperor’s plans have been pushed back, the rebellion has not yet succeeded.  Instead, its forces, hunted by imperial fleet elements, have fled to a tiny planet on the edge of the galaxy, in the area called the Outer Rim.  Their hiding place is discovered, however, and, in a desperate rearguard action, they’re forced to flee.

image26hoth.jpg

As they do so, Luke doesn’t join the retreat, but, instead, heads off to Dagobah, where he is to be trained as a Jedi by Yoda, one of the tiny number of surviving Jedi.

image27yoda.jpg

This would seem to continue the pattern of the previous film:  Luke will be the “new hope” which will successfully confront the Empire.  Then, in mid-training, Luke has a vision of his friends in trouble on another planet, Bespin, and he leaves Yoda to rescue them.  It’s a near-disaster, as, although with the aid of a new character, Lando,

image28lando.jpg

some of his friends are rescued, Han is captured

image29carbonite.jpg

to be sent off to his one-time employer, Jabba the Hutt,

image30jabba.jpeg

and Luke is faced with Darth Vader, who not only defeats him in a duel, cutting off his right hand, but reveals that he is Luke’s actual father.

image31iam.jpg

And so, the promising build of the first film has come nearly crashing down at the end of the second.  This is a trilogy, however, so that “new hope” is still there.  After all, although Han is a prisoner, Luke has been rescued and given a bionic hand, and, in the third film, The Return of the Jedi,

image32return.jpg

we see that new hope once more as Luke works out the retrieval not only of Han, but of all his friends, as well as the destruction of Jabba the Hutt.

image33barge.png

When Luke attempts to return to Yoda to complete his training, however, he finds a dying teacher

image34yoda.jpg

and, soon, a resurgent Death Star.

image35deathstar.jpg

The conclusion of this trilogy isn’t so predictable as its destruction and the eventual death of Darth Vader, however.  Luke, unlike his father, doesn’t suffer from the same flaws of fear and anger.  Instead, he confronts his father in a scene in which, ultimately, his insistence that there is still good in him comes true and Darth Vader turns back into Anakin Skywalker while destroying the Emperor, dying in the process.

image36emp.jpg

But that new hope, promised in the first episode of the trilogy, has come true, it seems.  The Emperor is gone, Anakin has been saved, and, with the general celebrations throughout the galaxy, the suggestion is, at least, that the Empire is gone as well.

All of that being the case, what is there to do in the third trilogy?

As always, thanks for reading and

MTCIDC

CD

ps

And that second Death Star was destroyed, of course, but by a secondary character.

image37ds.jpg

 

 

 

The Halls of Awaiting

22 Wednesday Jan 2020

Posted by Ollamh in J.R.R. Tolkien, Tolkien, Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Christopher Tolkien

Welcome, dear readers, as always.

This was meant to be the next in our slow-motion review of Star Wars IX:  The Rise of Skywalker, but the news of Christopher Tolkien’s death on January 15th made us stop to think of and to be thankful for him.

image1ct.jpg

Tolkien had celebrated a birthday in November and, whereas he had not, like Bilbo, who, at 131, had managed to outlive the Old Took (Gerontius, who died at 130), still, at 95, had long surpassed Frodo, who traveled to the Grey Havens at 53.  (Picture by one of our favorite Tolkien illustrators, Ted Nasmith.)

image2gh.jpg

Bilbo’s long life had allowed him to compile and edit not only his diary of his days on the expedition to the Lonely Mountain with the dwarves (There and Back Again), but also “many loose leaves of notes”, which he left for Frodo, along with three volumes of “Translations from the Elvish”.  (For more on all of this, see “Note on the Shire Records” in the Prologue to The Fellowship of the Ring.)

Like Bilbo, Christopher Tolkien had also been a compiler and editor during his long life, as well as the first reader for much of his father’s work while he was serving in the RAF (Royal Air Force), much of the time in South Africa, during World War 2 and the original cartographer for that same work, collaborating with his father.

After JRRT’s death in 1973, Tolkien went on to edit and publish what sometimes appear to be countless of his father’s unpublished manuscripts, allowing us to see into the complex creative process which gave us not only the material around The Lord of the Rings, but so much more of the history of Middle-earth in general.

image3vols.jpg

Beyond those, there were other works, some of them quite early, including Beren and Luthien, the first draft of which JRRT had written in 1917.

image4beren.jpg

In that story, Luthien, after Beren’s death, having died and gone to the Halls of Mandos (also called the Halls of Awaiting, where men and elves went after death) on Valinor,

image5map.gif

sings a song which is so powerful that it persuades Mandos to restore both her and Beren to life.  To JRRT, Luthien was his wife, Edith,

image6edithand.jpg

and, although he laments to Christopher, after her death:

“But the story has gone crooked, & I am left, and I cannot plead before the inexorable Mandos.” (Letters, 420)

we hope that something of the power of that song will take Christopher to his own Valinor, with our thanks for the riches he has left with us.

Thanks, as ever, for reading, and

MTCIDC

CD

Three Times Three (2)

15 Wednesday Jan 2020

Posted by Ollamh in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Welcome, dear readers, as we continue our slow-motion review of Star Wars IX:  The Rise of Skywalker.

image1poster.jpg

As we said in our last, we thought that it might be useful, and we hope, interesting, to review it by seeing it as we imagine the creators did, as the final installment of something which began almost as “long ago” as that well-known subtitle says the story took place.

We begin with the idea of trilogies.

In Western story-telling, three is a kind of magic number—almost an embodiment of the English proverb, “Third time pays for all”, where the third of three things completes something.   Fairy tales, for instance often involve three wishes.  Sometimes that third wish is a corrective, when the first two take the story in a bad direction.  In the story of “The Fisherman’s wife”, one of the tales in the Grimm Brothers’ collection of German fairy tales, the greedy fisherman’s wife even asks for a fourth wish–and loses everything the first three have given her.  (If you don’t know this story, here’s a LINK to the 1868 edition of the first English translation (1823) of it, by Edgar Taylor:  https://ia600907.us.archive.org/12/items/germanpopularsto01grim/germanpopularsto01grim.pdf).

When we think of books written to be read in a three, we might think of Suzanne Collins’ Hunger Games,

image2games.jpg

or Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials

image3materials.jpg

(if you’ve read these in the US, you’ll know that first volume, Northern Lights, by another title, The Golden Compass)

or, of course, Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings

image4lord.jpg

(although it was never designed to be such—early 1950s British printing demands broke what was thought of as a single work into three).

In the case of Star Wars, however, there is not one trilogy, but three.

image5sw.jpg

(actually 2 and 2/3s—IX is not yet commercially available, but here it is for completeness).

image6rise.jpg

Reading about the problems the original director/main writer, George Lucas,

image7gl.jpg

faced in gradually developing the story, we learn that, for a time, his plans kept changing until he finally settled on beginning the big story not with I, but with IV.

image8hope.jpg

Instead of returning to I after that, however, he went on to make his first trilogy of IV, V, and VI.

image9trilogy.jpg

Ultimately, the two main characters of this trilogy are Luke Skywalker and his antagonist, Darth Vader.

image10landd.jpg

In this second trilogy—although really the first in the series—Lucas had set his audiences what seemed to be several puzzles:

  1. who was Darth Vader—and why/how does he turn out to be (no spoiler alert here, we’re pretty sure!) Luke’s father? (and, we’d add, “Who’s his mother?”)
  2. what is the more general context—among other things, there’s talk of a republic and its senate, of “Jedi”, and then of the galaxy being ruled by an evil emperor who, when we see him, employs powers he derives from the “dark side” of “The Force”—so where does all of this come from?

And so, in this first trilogy (shown here with the second, as images of the first trilogy seem hard to find),

image11a.jpg

not only has the author given us several puzzles, but he’s seemingly set himself what might prove to be a very difficult task.  If he tells the story of Darth Vader in the first set of three films, Vader has already appeared as such a monster that it might be impossible to generate any sympathy for him, making him simply a two-dimensional villain of the sort the emperor appears to be in the second trilogy, and any films in which he is a main, if not the main, character, could be mostly just a series of repetitions of his evil behavior.  Instead, Star Wars I

image11phantom.jpg

begins with two of those Jedi, a master (as he’s called by the other), and an apprentice (called a “padawan”), Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan.

image12qg&ow.jpg

During their adventures, they encounter the Queen of Naboo, Padme,

image13padme.jpg

and what appears to be a kind of child prodigy, Anakin.

image14anakin.jpg

Qui-Gon decides that Anakin is something called “the Chosen One”, who is to “bring balance to the Force” and proposes to adopt him as his next padawan/apprentice.  The difficulty with this, as we are told in time, is that Jedi:

  1. must be without fear or anger
  2. must renounce all attachments

Anakin, still a little boy, must leave his mother, Shmi (short for Lakshmi, after the Hindu goddess of good fortune?)

image15shmi.jpg

and is obviously troubled about this:  a possible serious flaw in his becoming a Jedi, let alone “the Chosen One”.

Qui-Gon is killed in a duel with a mysterious figure called “Darth Maul”,

image17a.jpg

who is, in turn, cut in two by Obi-Wan,

image17owanddm.jpg

and, at the conclusion of this first film, Obi-Wan, now a Jedi himself, pledges to become Anakin’s master,

image18owanda.jpg

much against the will of a senior Jedi, Yoda, who has examined the boy and seen very clearly that flaw, along with his possibilities.

image19yoda.jpg

So far, then, the story is about promise, that Anakin will grow into a Jedi, but also a threat:  will Yoda’s doubts be proved correct?  And who was Darth Maul and why was he despatched on what looks like an assassination attempt?  We are briefly told that he was a “Sith” and the equivalent of a padawan, with the addition that, where there is one Sith, there is always one more…

The second film, Attack of the Clones,

image20attack.jpg

seems to take place about 10 years later:  Obi-Wan is now a settled Jedi (with a beard) and Anakin is a sort of senior apprentice, who nurses a growing sense of resentment that he’s never recognized as he believes he should be for his abilities.

image21owanda.jpg

At this point, Padme, now a member of the Galactic Senate, reappears,

image22padme.jpg

having just survived an assassination attempt.  Anakin confesses his attraction for her and, added to his anger, we see the very beginnings of what Yoda has always feared.

image23panda.jpg

This is only intensified when Anakin discovers that his mother has been captured on his home planet of Tatooine by Sand People and, basically, tortured to death.

image24aands.jpg

Beyond the personal, we see that the Republic is falling apart:  a number of planetary systems within the Galaxy are struggling to separate themselves.  The current Supreme Chancellor is forced to step down and, in his place, another senator from Naboo, Palpatine, is his replacement.  We saw Palpatine briefly in the first film and we see him again here and he seems like a sympathetic, if minor, figure.  Fatherless himself, and increasingly estranged from Obi-Wan, Anakin is drawn to him.

By the end of the second film, developments have come in quick succession:  the rebellion of the Separatists is being fueled by a one-time Jedi, Count Dooku; to defend itself, the remaining members of the Senate vote to form an army—only to find that there already is one, an army of clones; and Padme has fallen in love with Anakin and they secretly marry.

image25mawidge.jpg

We now come to the last of this first trilogy with Revenge of the Sith.

image26revenge.jpg

In a way, the title says it all:  Senator Palpatine is revealed as the Sith lord, Darth Sidious, and Anakin, corrupted by his fears for Padme’s death in childbirth and Sidious’ suggestion that, as a Sith, he knows ways to deal with death, joins him as his apprentice, Darth Vader, as Sidious activates Order 66.  It seems that, behind that mysterious clone army is Sidious himself, who has also been behind the Separatists, all to overthrow the Republic and become Galactic emperor.  This, however, is only one of two goals.  The other is the complete destruction of the Jedi order and Order 66 is the command, implanted in the clones, to murder all of the Jedi without question.

image27sid.jpg

 

image28a.jpg

This then leads to the climactic battle between Obi-Wan and Anakin/Darth Vader,

image29fight.jpg

in which Obi-Wan reluctantly defends himself but eventually defeats Anakin, who is left sprawled and mutilated, while Obi-Wan escapes with Padme, whom a jealous Anakin has nearly murdered.  She dies, however, just as Anakin feared, in childbirth, leaving behind twins, Luke and Leia, who, to protect them from the murderous Darth Sidious, are to be raised on separate planets, Leia on Alderan and Luke on Tatooine.

image30padme.jpg

Meanwhile, the dying Anakin is rescued by Sidious and reconstructed within the black armor in which we know Darth Vader, Sidious assuring him that he has killed Padme in his rage.

image31dv.jpg

Yoda and Obi-Wan, two of the very few surviving Jedi, both disappear into exile, and we are left with the image of baby Luke in the arms of his foster parents, Beru and Owen, initiating a scene we will view again in the first film of the second trilogy.

image32sunset.jpg

So, in the three films of this first trilogy, we see:

  1. the fall of the Republic and the rise of the Sith Darth Sidious as Galactic emperor
  2. the destruction of the Jedi, with two notable exceptions
  3. the failure of Anakin as “the Chosen One” and his rebirth as the apprentice of the greatest enemy of the Jedi
  4. and yet we also see Anakin’s children, who will reappear in the fourth film, perhaps optimistically titled A New Hope?

We shall see in our next, even as we thank you for reading this posting, with a promise, rather than a hope, that

MTCIDC

CD

 

Three Times Three (1)

08 Wednesday Jan 2020

Posted by Ollamh in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Welcome, dear readers, as always.

Recently, we saw Star Wars IX:  The Rise of Skywalker

image1poster.jpg

and we’d like to talk with you a bit about it.  If you follow this complex world, you’ve probably read reviews and even seen the film, as we have.  If so, you know that the reviews have been a wild mixture, although the tone among many has been dismissive and disappointed.

For us, the feelings were much more complicated.  After all, our first view of this world was with Star Wars IV:  A New Hope,

image2poster.jpg

the subtitle of which, to us, who loved adventure stories—especially long, complex ones—was true.  Suddenly, we were in “a galaxy far, far away” in a time “long, long ago”:  phrases which sounded as traditional as “once upon a time” or “a king there was upon Ireland”, but phrases which indicated a hope for many new stories about new characters in new places.

And that hope has been fulfilled, over and over–

image3onethroughsix.jpg

image4seven.jpg

image5eight.png

And not just with the slow but steady building of the main story, but with stories around the edges, from animated features like the Clone Wars

image6clone.jpg

and Rebels

image7rebels.jpg

to Rogue One

 

image8rogue.jpg

to Solo.

image9solo.jpg

And this is not to mention all of the novels, comic books, graphic novels, games, costumes, toys—some of the toys being our favorites…

 

image10figures.png

 

atat.jpg

as well as the bits of dialogue like:

image11lukeandhan.jpg

“She’s rich.”

“Rich?”

“Rich, powerful.  Listen, if you were to rescue her, the reward would be…”

“What?”

“Well, more wealth than you can imagine!”

“I don’t know, I can imagine quite a bit.”

And

image12yodaluke.jpg

“Do or do not.  There is no try.”

Thinking of all of those things and much more and how they all began with one film, made us think of the long, complex history of the story of Troy.  Unlike Star Wars, this didn’t begin with one identifiable man,

image13gl.jpg

but with an oral tradition of singers, aoidoi, in Greek,

image14aoidos.jpg

who gradually spread and embellished upon what was probably once a song about a raid

image15raid.jpg

but which, as it grew, included not only Greek adventures, like the homecoming of Odysseus,

image16ody.jpg

but even Roman, with the escape from the collapsing city of the Trojan prince, Aeneas, who then, in Italy, will begin the process which will lead, in time, to the founding of Rome.

image17aeneas.jpg

The same could be said for the King Arthur story, which may have begun with a tale about a kind of vague post-Roman historical figure,

image18art.jpg

and became, in western Europe, the center of a web of medieval stories and spin-offs

image19medart.jpg

up to the present (and who can forget Monty Python and the Holy Grail?).

image20mp.jpg

Here’s a LINK to some—and it’s only some—of those treatments and spin-offs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_works_based_on_Arthurian_legends#Film

Because the story is so complicated and because our reactions to IX are also so complicated, we thought that we’d tackle our review a little like the original, by moving in three postings, one to cover each trilogy, leading up, at the end of the third, to our reaction—reactions, really—to the final episode (with a spoiler alert:  we will not grumble, complain, or condemn IX, only try to understand what it is trying to do and what we are feeling about what we understand, with a huge amount of gratitude for all that the series has given us along the way).

So, thanks for reading, as always, and definitely

MTCIDC

CD

ps

If you haven’t seen it, we definitely recommend the Camelot Project sponsored by the University of Rochester (the US one) at this LINK:  https://d.lib.rochester.edu/camelot/theme/arthur

 

 

 

As All Should Know?

01 Wednesday Jan 2020

Posted by Ollamh in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

“ ‘Then what is Durin’s Day?’ asked Elrond.

‘The first day of the dwarves’ New Year,’ said Thorin, ‘is as all should know the first day of the last moon of Autumn on the threshold of Winter.’ “ (The Hobbit, Chapter Three, “A Short Rest”)

Welcome, dear readers, to our end-of-the-year posting.  It will be posted on January 1, 2020—which is hardly Durin’s Day.

But when is Durin’s Day?

It seems that that is as much a puzzle for Thorin as it might be for us, as he says:

“ ‘We call it Durin’s Day when the last moon of Auturm and the sun are in the sky together.  But this will not help us much, I fear, for it passes our skill in these days to guess when such a time will come again.’ “

Thorin and Gandalf have consulted Elrond over the map of the Lonely Mountain made by (or for) Thror, Thorin’s grandfather, and Elrond has discovered that the map has more to tell than would first appear.

image1map.jpgAs, in the light of a crescent moon, Elrond

“held up the map and the white light shone through it.  ‘What is this?’ he said.  ‘There are moon-letters here, beside the plain runes…’ “

Those briefly-readable lunar runes (highlighted in white on our image), say:

“Stand by the grey stone when the thrush knocks…and the setting sun with the last light of Durin’s Day will shine upon the key-hole.”

Like the first day of the dwarves’ New Year, the first day of the Western New Year has been a bit of a mystery over the centuries, too.

Ultimately, our calendar comes from the Roman calendar and that calendar, at its beginnings, was already in trouble, and all because of that same moon which illuminates Thror’s map.

image2phases.jpg

Roman tradition said that this calendar had been edited by the founder of Rome, Romulus, here depicted murdering his twin brother, Remus, before introducing

image3rom.jpg

his ten-month lunar calendar.  His successor, Numa Pompilius,

image4numa.jpg

attempting to combine a solar with a lunar calendar, added two months, but was forced to add another, shorter, month, every two years so that the seasons and the calendar didn’t drift too far apart.  As this still caused difficulties, Julius Caesar, many centuries later,

image5jc.jpg

recently made “Dictator for Life” by the Senate, consulted an Alexandrian astronomer, Sosigenes, and redesigned the calendar with 12 months with a total of 365 ¼ days, an extra day being added every four years to fill out that ¼ day—that is, more or less, a solar year.  There are a lot of complications in this which we ourselves would roll our eyes over, so, if you would like more information, here’s the WIKI LINK:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_calendar.

The difficulty with this, as we understand it, is that that ¼ day is fractionally longer than a quarter and that, over many years, the seasons and the calendar still managed to drift apart, so that, by the early 1580s, there was a 10-day gap.  This was adjusted by a new calendar, authorized by Pope Gregory XIII, in 1582, which recalibrated things in such a way that we’re still using that system in 2019.

image6pope.jpg

But what about the first day of the Western New Year?

Originally, Romans, with a ten-month calendar (which is why we the names “Septem-ber, Octo-ber, Novem-ber, and Decem-ber”, even though, now, those names/numbers can no longer be correlated with the modern 12-month variety), marked the beginning of the New Year as late in March, at the time of the vernal equinox.   This was one of two days a year when day and night are approximately equal (the other is on the autumnal equinox, which, as the name suggests, is in the fall).  In 2020, that will be on March 20th.

Although the Roman Republic had established 1 January as the beginning of the civil year, when their two chief magistrates, the consuls, took office,

image7aconsuls.jpg

that late March date was still being used until, along with his 12-month reform, Caesar permanently moved the beginning of the year to the first day of the extra month named after the god of endings and beginnings, Janus.

image7janus.jpg

This shift also nicely fit in with the season of traditional Roman year-end festivities (which seemed to go on no matter what the calendar might be doing), including the Saturnalia,

image8saturnalia.jpg

and the later addition of the festival of Sol Invictus (the “unconquered sun”), all from mid-to-late December.

image9solinvictus.jpg

This worked until 567AD, when Christian clergy, meeting at the Council of Tours, decreed that 1 January still reeked of paganism and shifted the beginning of the year back to late March—March 25th, in fact, where it remained until Pope Gregory XIII (remember him?) revised the calendar and moved it back to 1 January.  Most of the West adopted this new version of the calendar rather speedily, except for Great Britain, which didn’t make the change until 1752.  (So, when you see that George Washington, for example, was born on 22 February, 1732, until he was about 20, he must have believed that he had been born on 11 February, 1731.)

But what about Durin’s Day? we asked some time ago.

We know that Thorin seems a bit unsure and that would appear to be true for his creator, as well.  The best guess (with the author sort of behind it) would be 19 October, but, if you want to pursue it farther than that, see this LINK:  http://thorinoakenshield.net/confusticate-and-bebother-these-dates-the-durins-day-dilemma/  The author does a very good job of, well, trying to deal with something JRRT once wrote in a note at the top of a page of revisions for the projected 1966 edition of The Hobbit, “Hobbit Time table is not very clear”.

In this world, however, in the West, 1 January remains the beginning of the year and we wish you a happy and prosperous one, no matter when/how you celebrate.

With thanks for reading, as always, and, as always

MTCIDC

CD

ps

The traditional New Year’s song in the English-speaking world is Robert Burn’s “Auld Lang Syne” (literally, “Old Long Since”) and our favorite version is that of Leopold Kozeluch (1747-1818).

image10kozeluch.jpg

Here’s a LINK so that you can hear it for yourself:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=INzME1iKkGE

 

The Doubtful Sea Series Facebook Page

The Doubtful Sea Series Facebook Page

  • Ollamh

Categories

  • Artists and Illustrators
  • Economics in Middle-earth
  • Fairy Tales and Myths
  • Films and Music
  • Games
  • Heroes
  • Imaginary History
  • J.R.R. Tolkien
  • Language
  • Literary History
  • Maps
  • Medieval Russia
  • Military History
  • Military History of Middle-earth
  • Narnia
  • Narrative Methods
  • Poetry
  • Research
  • Star Wars
  • Terra Australis
  • The Rohirrim
  • Theatre and Performance
  • Tolkien
  • Uncategorized
  • Villains
  • Writing as Collaborators
Follow doubtfulsea on WordPress.com

Across the Doubtful Sea

Recent Postings

  • Phoebe June 7, 2023
  • Beato Te May 31, 2023
  • Phobe May 24, 2023
  • Vivant Reges—et Reginae May 17, 2023
  • Name of the Game, Game of the Name May 10, 2023
  • Goth-ic May 3, 2023
  • Coffee Break April 26, 2023
  • Changing Horses April 19, 2023
  • Sigilry April 12, 2023

Blog Statistics

  • 73,076 Views

Posting Archive

  • June 2023 (1)
  • May 2023 (5)
  • April 2023 (4)
  • March 2023 (5)
  • February 2023 (4)
  • January 2023 (4)
  • December 2022 (4)
  • November 2022 (5)
  • October 2022 (4)
  • September 2022 (4)
  • August 2022 (5)
  • July 2022 (4)
  • June 2022 (5)
  • May 2022 (4)
  • April 2022 (4)
  • March 2022 (5)
  • February 2022 (4)
  • January 2022 (4)
  • December 2021 (5)
  • November 2021 (4)
  • October 2021 (4)
  • September 2021 (5)
  • August 2021 (4)
  • July 2021 (4)
  • June 2021 (5)
  • May 2021 (4)
  • April 2021 (4)
  • March 2021 (5)
  • February 2021 (4)
  • January 2021 (4)
  • December 2020 (5)
  • November 2020 (4)
  • October 2020 (4)
  • September 2020 (5)
  • August 2020 (4)
  • July 2020 (5)
  • June 2020 (4)
  • May 2020 (4)
  • April 2020 (5)
  • March 2020 (4)
  • February 2020 (4)
  • January 2020 (6)
  • December 2019 (4)
  • November 2019 (4)
  • October 2019 (5)
  • September 2019 (4)
  • August 2019 (4)
  • July 2019 (5)
  • June 2019 (4)
  • May 2019 (5)
  • April 2019 (4)
  • March 2019 (4)
  • February 2019 (4)
  • January 2019 (5)
  • December 2018 (4)
  • November 2018 (4)
  • October 2018 (5)
  • September 2018 (4)
  • August 2018 (5)
  • July 2018 (4)
  • June 2018 (4)
  • May 2018 (5)
  • April 2018 (4)
  • March 2018 (4)
  • February 2018 (4)
  • January 2018 (5)
  • December 2017 (4)
  • November 2017 (4)
  • October 2017 (4)
  • September 2017 (4)
  • August 2017 (5)
  • July 2017 (4)
  • June 2017 (4)
  • May 2017 (5)
  • April 2017 (4)
  • March 2017 (5)
  • February 2017 (4)
  • January 2017 (4)
  • December 2016 (4)
  • November 2016 (5)
  • October 2016 (6)
  • September 2016 (5)
  • August 2016 (5)
  • July 2016 (5)
  • June 2016 (5)
  • May 2016 (4)
  • April 2016 (4)
  • March 2016 (5)
  • February 2016 (4)
  • January 2016 (4)
  • December 2015 (5)
  • November 2015 (5)
  • October 2015 (4)
  • September 2015 (5)
  • August 2015 (4)
  • July 2015 (5)
  • June 2015 (5)
  • May 2015 (4)
  • April 2015 (3)
  • March 2015 (4)
  • February 2015 (4)
  • January 2015 (4)
  • December 2014 (5)
  • November 2014 (4)
  • October 2014 (6)
  • September 2014 (1)

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • doubtfulsea
    • Join 70 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • doubtfulsea
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...